astonio wrote:He's SUCH a 14-year old girl....
My thoughts exactly!
astonio wrote:He's SUCH a 14-year old girl....
Sums it up nicely... Katco have an "expert" in most area's of Shattered Hopes, surely they'll need a gun expert for Part 3... Let's hope he's as thorough as you.scipio-USMC wrote:The bottom line is that the gun found is an Iver Johnson Third Model Safety Hammer. They were manufactured 1909-41 and came in two different sizes. The smaller one 4 3/16 long X 3.75” tall and the larger one 5 inches long X 3 7/8” tall. The size difference is too close to be able to figure out from the photo which size the one they found is. The larger frame came in .32 Special and .38 S&W while the smaller frame came in .32 S&W and .22 rimfire.
Anyone who thinks a 38 S&W would shatter the ribs and continue right through the body and through the bed into the box spring just like the undisputed rifle rounds has no understanding of ballistics at all.
This is a matter of physics and other sciences.
Roxanne Salch Kaplan
And he was actually from the "truth" forum?!
SHATTERED HOPES: THE TRUE STORY OF THE AMITYVILLE MURDERS
Yeah....*rolls eyes*...Apparently when I don't read their forum or pay attention to the petulant behavior, they feel the need to come over here with their smelly diapers to drone on endlessly with their oh-so-stunning (ill-informed) insights. I guess it's to be expected when you deal with children.
Actually the whole "feud" with this site makes him look even more childish and ridiculous.kathyM wrote:I find it silly that Ryan wont let his peeps see anything Scipio posted. After all, we listened to Whisper babble for weeks and didnt stop her and she is still even welcome here. Why not allow any discussion between them? Ryan must not have much faith that his followers will still follow him if he has to control everything that is being posted. Scipio was not disrespectful yet Ryan deletes all the posts and then makes out Scipio to be some kind of crazy member of this board.
First of all, Scipio hasnt even been here but a few weeks so he has no loyality to this board to defend over at Ryan's page. Scipio is just a person with some very good points and questions that Ryan wont or cant seem to answer.
How many dvds have you sold so far?
Note how he still refuses to address my points and has not addressed the William Davidge issue either. If I were in his place and it were shown that Billy was still in AMityville and graduated there as opposed to being in Florida like he claimed I would sure want to address it.kathyM wrote:
I am glad that nobody outside of Ryan's facebook page take him seriously or even know about his fakeumentary. And no, CBS only reported the story because of the popularity of the Amityville haunting story, not because they take the whole gun thing seriously especially since they reported the Suffolk County Police Department doesnt take it seriously.
He's such a hypocritical bastard. He banned me from his board because I said here that he was acting like a child, which he was and still is. Before he banned me I never said one bad thing against him other than commenting on his childish behavior. Personally, after seeing his antics for these past few months my opinion of Ryan is that he is one major douchebag. Would that make his minions douchettes?TigresMeow wrote:Ryan accuses us of acting like children who need attention???? Is he serious???? He is the one that deleted Scipio's post because he cannot or will not debate this yet we are the immature ones?? Maybe Ryan should check his own diaper before he flings poo at others.
I am laughing so hard at that I am in tears. Real mature statement there, Ryan.
It will take you 5 hours to address my points? Then you are in big trouble because part 3 is shorter than that.
^infinity! I bet Ryan nearly had a heartattack when he read that! LOL^infinity!I can just file a FOIL request and get these document anyway if you actually sent them something my request might reveal you didn't.
Ryan and Ric have not been had but rather knew that Geraldine was a fraud all along and that her tales can't be true. Osuna knowingly relied upon recanted affidavits without mentioning the fact the affiants recanted. He demonstrated he was familiar with the 440 motion ruling that discussed the very issue of testimony on the issue. He intentionally chose to rely on recanted claims and statements including the story he claims Ron told him which was either recanted or made up. Osuna visited Ron once- he can't have relayed all the details in the book in that single visit thus even if Ron did tell him something most of the book still had to have been made up by Geraldine.FoxyJ wrote:Thanks again Scipio for another well researched and informative post. I found the illustrations/descriptions interesting even though I know that only RJD's Marlin was fired in the house that night - there is absolutely zero evidence of another weapon having been used to murder the DeFeo family. I dare say that if they pulled out the plug from the Amityville river they would find a squillion different types of rusting weapons, plus the obligatory teaspoon!
My feeling has always been that Messrs. K and O know full well, and have done for some time, that they have been 'had' by, in the first instance Ron and latterly Mrs. G; they have a considerable amount of egg-on-face but embarrassment precludes their admitting their mistake and they stand to lose financially should they recant at this (too) late stage; they're between a rock and a hard place; they have only themselves to blame. The amount of insult-hurling and banning coming from the SH Pages simply confirms my opinion. However, knowing they've been right royally duped and yet to continue to defame the memories of innocent people is thoroughly shameful.
At first I gave them the benefit of the doubt but the more I learned about the facts and the more I saw them in action the more it was apparent they were not "innocent Madoff victims" but rather were people knowingly peddling "Madoff's ponzi scheme" for a cut of the proceeds.FoxyJ wrote:You're right of course Scipio - I have a tendency to be over-generous. I have read every word you've written here.
I did, however, spend twenty quid for Mr. O's penny-dreadful so have only myself to blame for getting carried away!